Jefferson Co. Sheriff Seeks Assistance of Hunters in Double Homicide Case from 2020

Kevin P. Anderson [U.S. Marshalls Service]

By Lynn Binnie
Whitewater Banner volunteer staff
whitewaterbanner@gmail.com

The Jefferson County Sheriff issued a press release on November 13 soliciting help from hunters, specifically around STH 106/CTH A, in watching for anything that may lead to a conclusion in a double homicide case involving suspect Kevin P. Anderson. It was stated that the case remains active while Anderson remains at large, and the agency has continued to follow up on leads generated from across the country.

On June 16, 2020 Kevin P. Anderson is alleged to have shot and killed his sister and brother-in-law, Nedra J. and James H. Lemke, at their family farm in rural Jefferson County. Anderson then proceeded to burn the farm house down and shot at a sheriff’s deputy responding to the farm. Anderson is believed to have fled the area as no remains were found in the farm house. Anderson is an avid hunter and camper. He is charged with two counts of first-degree intentional homicide, one count of attempted intentional first-degree homicide, one count of arson, and one count of felon in possession of a firearm.

Kevin P. Anderson [Jefferson Co. Sheriff]

Anderson is described as a white male in his mid 60’s, 6’0″ tall, weighs about 200 lbs., has blue eyes, and balding brown hair.

Anyone seeing Anderson, who should be considered armed and dangerous, should not approach him but should immediately contact local law enforcement. Anyone who believes they have seen Anderson, have any knowledge of his whereabouts, or information to share pertaining to this case, should contact the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office at 920-674-7310.

Share This
Posted in

Other Recent Posts

Our Readers Share: Ed Grosskreutz – Activity around Trippe Lake

Nelson Named to FIRST Wisconsin Youth Advisory Council

WMTV: ‘It’s extremely shocking;’ Whitewater police detail major internet crimes against children investigation

Unity Walk Saturday the 12th at 10 a.m.; Marcha por la unidad

Happy Labor Day

FCCU Announces Promotion of Whitney Townsend to Chief Strategy Officer

Our Readers Share: Ron Binning – Monarch on our zinnia

Boys’ Soccer Continues to Play Strong

Warhawks Open 2026 with Record-Breaking Day at Perkins Stadium

Fiber Fridays Hosted by the Whitewater Public Library

Film at Seniors in the Park Tuesday, Sept. 8

John’s Disposal Holiday Schedule

This Week’s City & School Board Meetings

Wisconsin Makers to Offer Open Art Workshops

Obituary: Amanda Jean Hunter, 49