ProPublica Features Our City: The Police Chief & The Immigrant

By Lynn Binnie
Whitewater Banner volunteer staff
whitewaterbanner@gmail.com

ProPublica, a Pulitzer prize winning nonprofit news organization with the tagline, “Investigative Journalism in the Public Interest,” published an article about Whitewater on their website that was initially titled “The Police Chief and the Immigrant” on October 24. Eventually the headline was changed to “What Happened in Whitewater: How immigration is affecting one small Wisconsin city.” It’s a very lengthy article, with over 5700 words. An audio recording that is provided is over 34 minutes long. Normally The Whitewater Banner would print a few quotes from such a piece, but we are honoring ProPublica’s requirement that their articles only be reprinted in their entirety. Photos, however, could not be reprinted. The Banner has used one of their photos on the homepage under the practice of fair use.

The lead author of the article, Melissa Sanchez, is a Chicago-based reporter who focuses on immigration and low wage-workers.  She is the daughter of immigrants from Mexico and El Salvador, and she speaks Spanish. Sanchez and other ProPublica journalists have visited the city over a dozen times since January, conducting many interviews with city staff, long-term residents and recent immigrants. Police Chief Dan Meyer told The Whitewater Banner that he has spoken with Melissa seven or eight times, and “has nothing but good things to say” about her. She really poured a lot of time into her research and writing the article, he said. Meyer felt that his comments were fairly represented in the article, and that “it’s about as balanced” as could be expected. Undoubtedly readers will have varying opinions, and Meyer expressed his view that “opinions need to get out there to make progress.” The Banner’s Facebook page does allow for comments to be made, with the trust that kindness and civility be evidenced. The ProPublica article may be accessed here.

Background

In December, 2023, City of Whitewater Police Chief Dan Meyer composed a letter to President Biden regarding the challenges faced by our relatively small community in serving the estimated 800-1000 immigrants who had arrived, primarily from Nicaragua, beginning in early 2022. Examples were given of the difficulties the Police Department was experiencing in communicating with this Spanish-speaking population, encountering many unlicensed drivers with fake IDs, and investigating some serious crimes. “None of this information is shared as a means of denigrating or vilifying this group of people,” the letter stated, “We know that challenges will come with the addition of any significant number of people to a City. In fact, we see great value in the increasing diversity that this group brings to our community. We simply need to ensure that we can continue to properly serve this group, and the entirety of the City of Whitewater.” The letter was also signed by City Manager John Weidl and Common Council members.

City staff and officials were shocked by how quickly state and national media picked up the story. A number of journalists have contacted them, and in some cases, even visited the city to develop stories that have sometimes included inaccuracies. A presidential candidate even mentioned the city’s challenges. Little governmental assistance has resulted from the plea, although the city was recently awarded a grant totaling $375,000 over three years to assist with the hiring of three additional police officers.

Obituary: Nancy Ungerer Duval, M.D., 75, of Florida

Nancy Ungerer Duval, M.D. was born on October 9, 1948 to Glenn May Ungerer and Elizabeth Elsie Ungerer in Buffalo, New York.  She was raised in the Buffalo suburb of Amherst, and graduated from Amherst Central High School at age 16, having been advised to skip a grade in elementary school.  She attended Vassar College for two years before transferring to Northwestern University in Chicago, Illinois where she obtained her Bachelor of Science Degree.  While she may have preferred to attend veterinary school, she attended the University of Illinois Medical School where she obtained her medical degree, and did a residency in Pediatrics at Michael Reese Hospital in Chicago. As she finished her residency, she decided to specialize in the emerging field of Emergency Medicine and took additional training in adult medicine and critical care, becoming board certified in both specialties.  She worked most of her career in Emergency Medicine at Good Shepherd Hospital in Barrington, Illinois and also was on the teaching faculty at Northwestern where she taught residents in the emergency room.   

Nancy was a trailblazer for women in the medical field.  After a lengthy screening process, she was chosen to winter over at Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station in Antarctica in 1984-85, serving as the doctor, dentist, postmaster and guardian of the liquor supply.  In preparation, she received training in dentistry, as well as survival skills on the ice in New Zealand.  While at the South Pole, she became a member of the elite 200 Degree Club, an event that involves experiencing an immediate 200 degree drop transitioning from sauna to a total polar plunge. 

She and her late husband, Thomas Duval, lived actively in their Barrington Hills, Illinois community for years: enjoying horses, Cubs games, and the active life of the local hunt club.  They parented Newfoundland and Corgi dogs.  Tom and Nancy relocated to Whitewater, Wisconsin to be close to Tom’s family and their grandchildren and were actively involved in their lives for many years. In Whitewater,  Nancy worked at the U. of Wisconsin campus in the student health clinic. While living in Whitewater, they enjoyed boating, golf and bicycling. They also had a great group of friends at the Whitewater Golf Course and enjoyed going out for fish frys at 5 pm. Nancy always thought of Whitewater as a hidden gem.

Nancy and Tom retired to Sebastian, Florida.  Once again, they immersed themselves into the local community and became active participants in their homeowners association and developed long-lasting friendships with their new tribe there. 

Nancy was predeceased by her husband, Thomas Duval of 25 years, after a long and difficult struggle with his chronic illness.   Nancy took care of him until he passed.  She is survived by her brothers, Robert (Beverly) Ungerer, M.D. and Ronald (Stephanie) Ungerer, M.D.  She was aunt to Natasha, Rachel, Olivia, Mary Ungerer and Mark and Andrew Ungerer.  She was a great-aunt to 10 nieces and 7 nephews.  She was stepmother to Tom Jr. “Beau” DuVal (Julie) and Jerry Duval (Julie) and step-grandmother to Emma, Jimmy and Tommy, Clayton and Blaise.

Nancy passed away from cancer May 3, 2024, which she had dealt with for 3 years.  A Celebration of Life was held August 18, 2024 in Sebastian, Florida.  A sunrise gathering and memorial was held on the dock over the Indian River where Nancy and her close friends and their dogs had gathered at sunrise every morning for years.  Breakfast refreshments and a sharing of memories followed the sunrise gathering, with a dedication of an ornamental tree and engraved bench in Nancy’s honor from her friends and the homeowners association. A later Celebration of Life with Family is planned at Whitewater Lake in Whitewater, Wisconsin, where they both loved to enjoy the sunsets and boat rides with family and friends.

Arts Alliance Meat Raffle – Sunday

Whitewater Arts Alliance Meat Raffle Fundraiser

Event Date: October 27, 2024, 12-3pm (approximately)

Event Location: Second Salem Brewery, 111 W.Whitewater St., Whitewater, WI

Whitewater,WI – The Whitewater Arts Alliance (WAA) will host a meat raffle fundraiser at Second Salem Brewing Co. on Sunday, October 27, 2024, starting at 12:00pm and ending when all prizes have been distributed, approximately 3:00pm.

The meat raffle will take place throughout the Packer game, with numbered paddles sold for $5 each round, with multiple winners called each round. Prizes include locally sourced meat from Little Red Farms in Whitewater and Wilson Farm Meats in Elkhorn, as well as from Aldi in Whitewater. In addition, there will be a 50/50 cash raffle as well as ticketed bucket raffles for goods donated by numerous local businesses and community members. 

All proceeds from the raffle will directly benefit the Whitewater Arts Alliance, supporting their mission to promote and sustain the arts in our community.

About Second Salem Brewing Co.

Second Salem Brewing Company is a brewpub located on Cravath Lake in historic downtown Whitewater, Wisconsin. Back in the early 20th century, Whitewater earned the moniker “Second Salem” from the locals, owing to its association with witch gatherings around the Witchtower (better known as the Starin Park water tower),as well as eerie incidents, mysterious deaths, and other unworldly occurrences in the lake. These intriguing events, along with the distinctive figures and architecture of that era, constitute a shared history that sets our town apart,offering a trove of captivating tales to infuse into our exceptional brews.

The Whitewater Water Tower is on the Ballot: Historical background

The Whitewater Water Tower
By Carol Cartwright

A question about the Starin Park Water Tower will be on the ballot on November 5. Here is some historical background about the water tower.

The Starin Park Water Tower was built in 1889 as part of the first water system built in Whitewater. It was one of the earliest water towers built in the area, has outstanding stone construction and an original tank, and it was the result of an effort to provide better fire protection and pure drinking water in the city.

In June of 1887, the city entertained a proposal from a private company to build a water system. At the time, most communities only considered a water system to provide water pressure for firefighting. In Whitewater, the Whitewater Register printed a lengthy article on the proposal for a water system and promoted an interesting view, citing sanitary reasons for a waterworks. The article stated that micro-organisms were readily found in water samples in town. As an afterthought, the article also mentioned that a water system was necessary for fighting fires and would result in a reduction of insurance rates.

In a second article in the Whitewater Register, the newspaper noted that private wells were the source of much “enfeebled health and shortened life.” Only a very deep artesian well assured pure water, and that “a careful examination of the subject has convinced the city officials that an artesian well is the best source of supply.”

In the spring of 1889, Gray Brothers of Milwaukee began construction on the waterworks system that included a well at the corner of Fremont Street and what is now Starin Road. At about 1000 feet, the workers hit a water supply with enough volume to fill a reservoir and to serve a city twice the size of Whitewater. The supply was submitted for testing at the University of Wisconsin in Madison and pronounced pure. The Gray Brothers then built a pumping works, a reservoir, a tower with elevated tank, water mains, hydrants, and fountains. Upon completion, the city paid the company to operate the system for 25 years.

On October 1, 1889, the waterworks components were completed and tested and found to be acceptable. One aspect of the test was to make sure that a stream of water could be thrown over the roof of the Normal School, located on a hill and the highest building in the city. The test showed that there was enough pressure to send water through 500 feet of hose onto the roof of the building.

The most impressive structure that was built for the water works was the water tower. The octagonal tower was built with limestone walls eight feet thick to a height of 80 feet. A steel tank, 30 feet in diameter and 32 feet tall, was built on top of the tower. The tank was built to hold 200,000 gallons of water, and with the 800,000 gallon capacity of the reservoir, the total supply on hand would equal 1,000,000 gallons, enough to provide excellent water pressure for both everyday usage and for emergency fire-fighting. After the private contract expired, Whitewater citizens voted to purchase and operate the system.

The water tower is an early and fine example of its type of structure. It is architecturally significant for its outstanding stone construction and intact metal tank, but it is also historically significant as the most intact resource related to the development of Whitewater’s waterworks, one of the most important city services ever developed in the community.

Editor’s note: Information regarding the non-binding water tower referendum that’s on the November 5 ballot may be found on the city website here.

City Announces Developer Meet and Greet Event – Community members welcome

The City of Whitewater is pleased to invite developers and community members to its inaugural Developer Meet and Greet. This event aims to foster connections and provide valuable insights into development opportunities within the city.

Attendees will benefit from presentations by key team members, including the Zoning Administrator, Neighborhood Services staff, the Economic Development Director, and additional support staff. These discussions will cover essential aspects of development processes, zoning regulations, and economic initiatives in Whitewater.

Following the presentations, a guided bus tour will showcase available parcels of land, offering an in-depth look at prime development opportunities in the community.

Event Details:

  • Date: Friday, November 1, 2024
  • Time: 10:00 AM to 1:00 PM
  • Location: Innovation Center, 1221 Innovation Drive, Whitewater, WI
    With space limited, we ask all interested participants to RSVP by Monday, October 28th, 4:30 PM
    to secure their spot.
    RSVP Contact Information: Bonnie Miller
    Phone: 262-473-0148
    Email: bmiller@whitewater-wi.gov

    The City of Whitewater is committed to supporting development and growth, and this event represents a significant step toward engaging with developers and the community to explore future opportunities.

    For more information about the city’s initiatives and updates, please visit the official
    website: www.whitewater-wi.gov.

Arts Alliance Members’ Show Call for Art – Due Sunday: New members welcome

Call for Art!! Entries due Sunday, Oct. 27

2024 Members’ Show

Each year the Whitewater Arts Alliance is delighted to showcase the outstanding 2D and 3D visual art produced by its members. Not a member? Special mid-year rates for the remainder of 2024 and all of 2025: Student $15; Senior (Age 62+) $50; Individual $95; Family (one household) $130. Join here.

The 2024 exhibit opens Friday, November 1 with a reception Sunday, November 3 at the Cultural Arts Center, 402 West Main Street in Whitewater.

Being eligible to exhibit in the Members’ Show is is one of the benefits of WAA membership. There is no fee to enter and WAA does not deduct commission on sales made during the show.

Entry forms must be completed online and are due by by Sunday, October 27, 2024. Learn more and enter here.

Seniors in the Park Presents Godzilla Minus One

October is a month for the macabre, mysterious moans, mammoth monsters…and Halloween! Three movies to induce mayhem! 

“Godzilla Minus One”

Tuesday, October 29, 1 pm 

(Epic/Monster/Horror) Rated PG-13; 2 hours, 4 minutes (2023)

In Japan, Godzilla is a revered pop culture icon and national hero. On November 3, 2024, after 40 films and over 70 years, Japan will be celebrating Godzilla Day. Don’t laugh. This film was the 2024 Oscar Winner for Best Achievement in Visual Effects, and is one of the highest/best rated films ever, by critics/audience.

(Certified Fresh Tomatoes). Personally, as a longtime Godzilla fan, I can tell you this is The. Best. Godzilla. Film. EVER.  Language: Japanese; English subtitles. 

Seniors in the Park is located in Starin Park, 504 W. Starin Road. Although there is no charge to attend, regular participants are encouraged to join Seniors in the Park. The annual fee for residents of the Whitewater Unified School District is $10 and non-residents is $15. The funds support about half of the cost of our front desk staff person for 15 hours per week. The rest comes our of our fundraising monies. If you cannot afford the fee, we have a fund that will cover it for you. Fees are accepted at the Starin Park Community Building or online at https://schedulesplus.com/wwtr/kiosk/

Early Voting Off to a Strong Start – Open today (Sat.)

Early in-person voting is available today, Saturday, October 26 from 8:00 a.m. – 4:30 p.m. at the City of Whitewater Municipal Building, 312 W. Whitewater St., 2nd Floor, Administration Window. See below for the remaining early in-person voting dates/times.

Heather Boehm, city clerk, told The Whitewater Banner that absentee and early in-person voting has been off to a strong start this week. As of the close of business on Friday, 514 ballots have been cast in person, and 713 absentee ballots have already been returned. That leaves only 228 absentee ballots outstanding. Currently a total of 5130 persons are registered to vote.

Statewide turnout has been so strong that the Wisconsin Election Commission’s database has been bogged down for much of the week, causing waits that have caused some clerks to handwrite the voter information that’s supposed to be provided on a sticker on the absentee envelope. At the end of the day they have to go back and generate the stickers.

Early voting times for next week:
Monday, October 28th, 2024 – 8:00 am-4:30 pm
Tuesday, October 29th, 2024 – 8:00 am-6:30 pm
Wednesday, October 30th, 2024 – 8:00 am-4:30 pm
Thursday, October 31st, 2024 – 8:00 am-4:30 pm
Friday, November 1st, 2024 – 8:00 am-5:00 pm

DROP BOX INFORMATION
Whitewater Municipal Building
312 W. Whitewater St.
Last pickup on election day is 8:00 p.m.
Drop box is located in the entryway on the Whitewater St. entrance. Please use the box that is labeled “Absentee ballots only.”

NOVEMBER 5TH, 2024 – GENERAL ELECTION
Voting Hours – 7 am-8 pm

Polling Locations:

The Downtown Armory, 146 W. North St.
WARDS: 1-7 and 11-12

UW – Whitewater
The University Center
190 Hamilton Green Way
Hamilton Room
WARDS: 8-10 and 13

Any Absentee Ballots being returned on Election Day MUST be returned to the Municipal Building, Council Chambers
, or the drop box in the Municipal Building Whitewater Street entrance. Absentee ballots may not be returned to either polling place.

This website allows you to do the following:

  • Check your current registration information
  • Update your name and address
  • Request an absentee ballot
  • Find your elected officials
  • Track your absentee ballot
  • View a list of elections you have voted in
  • Find your polling place
  • See what will be on your ballot
  • Register to vote

Obituary: Gretchen Joan Cutshall, 93, of Rochester, MN

Gretchen Joan Cutshall (Gentling), 93, of Rochester passed away surrounded by her family at Saint Marys Hospital on October 21, 2024. Gretchen was born in Rochester, MN on July 17, 1931, to Harold and Nellie (Larson) Gentling. She attended and graduated from Lourdes High School in Rochester. She married David Cutshall of Rochester in 1951. They had eight children together and were divorced in 1976. 

Gretchen worked at Rochester School District at Central Middle School and Willow Creek Middle School as a cook for over 20 years before she retired in 1996. She then volunteered at The Ronald McDonald House in Rochester for 27 years where she still worked as a greeter. She also served at the Church of the Resurrection helping with funerals, events, counting, and being an amazing friend to everyone. In September of 2024, she was honored with the Bishop’s Medal in grateful acknowledgement for her dedicated, generous service to Resurrection Parish. 

Her 8 children, 18 grandchildren, and 14 great-grandchildren were her pride and joy. The love for her family was unconditional and absolute. 

Gretchen loved life and had the most incredible smile and laugh. Her true passion was always taking care of others, often through her amazing cooking and baking. She enjoyed hardanger stitchery, loved playing cards, watching the Vikings and Twins, dancing, making snow angels, going on walks and adventures, being with family, and sitting down and talking to everyone she met while they became instant and life-long friends with her. 

She is survived by her children Daniel (Cheryl), Cathy (Bruce), Robert (Shirley), Thomas (Mary Ellen), Bradley (Susanne), William (Tawny), Gregory (Kathleen), her 18 grandchildren, and her 14 great-grandchildren and sisters Mary and Margaret. She was preceded in death by her daughter Pamela, her parents, brothers Richard, Armand, and John. 

A celebration of her life will be held at 12:00 p.m. Friday, November 8th, 2024, at the Church of the Resurrection. A visitation will be held two hours prior to the service on Friday at the church followed by a reception. 

The family would like to extend their appreciation for the care and support she received from the Mayo Clinic Hospital St Marys staff. 

Memorials are suggested to The Ronald McDonald House of Rochester. 

Online condolences are welcome at www.mackenfuneralhome.com 

Library Groundbreaking Reflections; No trick, just a treat: building reopens Oct. 31

As usual with construction, the mid-October target for reopening wasn’t achieved, but hope is in sight.

Diane Jaroch, library director, announced on October 24, “No trick, just a treat! The Irvin L. Young Memorial Library will reopen on Thursday, October 31st at 9:00 a.m.! Please use the new front entrance on Center Street, as there is no longer a back entrance. Our parking lot is now a construction zone, so please use street parking. Library items are not due until October 31st. There currently is no outside book drop, as the front entrance area is still a work in progress. Once the concrete sets and we are open to the public, we will be installing an outdoor book drop near the entrance to the library. [Patrons who can’t wait to return their books may do so at any of the other system libraries, including Fort Atkinson, Jefferson, or Palmyra.] We are very excited to have everyone back in the library to see the changes that were made while we were closed.”

As shown in the photo above, it seemed that ground had already been broken before the groundbreaking ceremony, as the entire west section of the building had been removed, but it was a celebrative occasion anyway.

The groundbreaking ceremony for the expansion and renovation of the Irvin L. Young Memorial Library drew a good sized group of library supporters on a beautiful October 2nd late afternoon. Jennifer Motszko, President of the Library Board of Trustees, welcomed everyone and thanked them for their attendance. The board’s vision for expanding the library extended back over two decades, she stated, and it was very rewarding to see that vision being fulfilled. Library Director Diane Jaroch emphasized that this project is designed not only to serve the current users but many future generations as well.

Kelly Davis spoke on behalf of Capital Campaign Committee Chair Jim Winship and Anne Hartwick, the Vice-Chair. Kelly shared, “We are all here because we either love libraries or cake or, most likely, both! We want to thank you all for being here on this momentous day for Whitewater AND for loving libraries.

Jim and Anne both regret not being here to celebrate with all of us. Jim is in Stevens Point, where he will deliver the keynote address for the Hunger Relief Federation Annual Summit tomorrow, a commitment he made in the spring of this year. Anne, who works for the American Cancer Society, is this evening taking over some of the responsibilities of her colleagues who have been impacted by Hurricane Helene, and are still without power.

On behalf of the committee, we are thrilled that we’ve reached this incredible milestone in our library’s history. If you can believe it, we’ve been working towards this expansion and renovation project since 2003. Today, we break ground on a new chapter for our cherished community institution – a place where people can come to read, learn, connect, create, and feel welcome.”

Davis concluded, “This achievement is the result of overwhelming support from our community and the City of Whitewater. The additional 4400 square feet and redesigned existing space will enhance children and youth engagement, foster literacy, increase accessibility, promote cultural connections, nurture creativity, and provide a friendly space for all. The design is based on input from the community, census data, state standards, and considerations for sustainability, resiliency, and technological needs. This expansion ensures our library will continue to be an equal-access institution, leveling the playing field so everyone may benefit from knowledge and education. As we put these shovels in the ground, we’re not just expanding a building; we’re expanding opportunities for learning, growth, and connection for generations to come. Thank you all — our donors, our city, and every community member — for supporting this vital project that will serve our community’s needs for decades to come.”

Photo gallery courtesy of Tom Ganser

A very creative and delicious cake topped off the occasion. [Binnie photo]